While this submission is a draft, it cannot be used by other submissions.

Slow spaces on a separable Banach space need not be measurable

Lax606786.SlowSpaceNonmeasurability · concepts/Lax606786/SlowSpaceNonmeasurability.lean · lax-606786

proven

Loading review…

Sign in with ORCID

Community review

Flags

Each flag is tied to a public ORCID identity and explains why this concept may be incorrect.

No flags have been submitted.

    Community review

    Flag this concept

    State precisely what appears incorrect. This explanation will be public under your ORCID name.

    No source line selected.

    Natural Language Statement

    Theorem

    Let Ω=R/Z\Omega = \mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} be the circle with Lebesgue measure, rotated by the irrational angle α=2\alpha = \sqrt2: σ(ω)=ω+α\sigma(\omega) = \omega + \alpha. Let X=ℓ1(Z)X = \ell^1(\mathbb{Z}) with its Borel σ\sigma-algebra, and e0e_0 its 00-th unit vector. For ω∈Ω\omega \in \Omega and i∈Zi \in \mathbb{Z} let si(ω)=1s_i(\omega) = 1 if the representative of ω+iα\omega + i\alpha in [0,1)[0, 1) lies in [0,12)[0, \tfrac12), and si(ω)=−1s_i(\omega) = -1 otherwise, and put

    φω(x)=∑i∈Zsi(ω) xi,Lωx=φω(x) e0.\varphi_\omega(x) = \sum_{i \in \mathbb{Z}} s_i(\omega)\, x_i, \qquad \mathcal{L}_\omega x = \varphi_\omega(x)\, e_0 .

    Then XX is separable, and L\mathcal{L} is a quasicompact cocycle over (Ω,σ)(\Omega, \sigma) with λ1=0\lambda_1 = 0 and λ2=−∞\lambda_2 = -\infty. For every ω\omega its slow space

    {x∈X:λω(x)≤λ2(ω)}=ker⁡φω\{x \in X : \lambda_\omega(x) \le \lambda_2(\omega)\} = \ker \varphi_\omega

    belongs to the Grassmannian GX\mathcal{G} X, yet there is no measurable map W:Ω→GXW : \Omega \to \mathcal{G} X with W(ω)W(\omega) equal to this slow space for every ω\omega. So separability of XX alone does not make the slow spaces of the Oseledets decomposition measurable.

    The mechanism is that of Horan (2020, Remark 4.5.7), who observes that for a family of Perron–Frobenius operators on BVBV at mutual distance at least 25\tfrac25, measurability of ω↦Lω\omega \mapsto \mathcal{L}_\omega would make arbitrary sets of base points measurable. Lee (2024, Example 35) gives a version over a full shift, on ℓ1(N0)\ell^1(\mathbb{N}_0) with φω\varphi_\omega summing from i=1i = 1; that functional vanishes on e0e_0, so here the sum runs over all coordinates.

    Concept map
    6 concepts
    100%
    Proven claimDefinitionThis conceptRelated conceptA → B: B builds on A
    Evidence

    Each proof establishes this claim relative to its assumptions.

    In the paper

    • page 18 of this submission's paper

    Lean source view on GitLab

    1import Lax606786.BanachGrassmannian
    2import Lax606786.Cocycles
    3import Mathlib.Analysis.Normed.Lp.lpSpace
    4import Mathlib.MeasureTheory.Constructions.Polish.Basic
    5import Mathlib.MeasureTheory.Integral.IntervalIntegral.Periodic
    6
    7/-!
    8---
    9title: Slow spaces on a separable Banach space need not be measurable
    10type: theorem
    11---
    12Let Ω=R/Z\Omega = \mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} be the circle with Lebesgue measure, rotated by the
    13irrational angle α=2\alpha = \sqrt2: σ(ω)=ω+α\sigma(\omega) = \omega + \alpha. Let
    14X=ℓ1(Z)X = \ell^1(\mathbb{Z}) with its Borel σ\sigma-algebra, and e0e_0 its
    1500-th unit vector. For ω∈Ω\omega \in \Omega and i∈Zi \in \mathbb{Z} let si(ω)=1s_i(\omega) = 1 if the
    16representative of ω+iα\omega + i\alpha in [0,1)[0, 1) lies in [0,12)[0, \tfrac12), and si(ω)=−1s_i(\omega) = -1
    17otherwise, and put
    18φω(x)=∑i∈Zsi(ω) xi,Lωx=φω(x) e0.\varphi_\omega(x) = \sum_{i \in \mathbb{Z}} s_i(\omega)\, x_i, \qquad \mathcal{L}_\omega x = \varphi_\omega(x)\, e_0 .
    19
    20Then XX is separable, and L\mathcal{L} is a quasicompact cocycle over (Ω,σ)(\Omega, \sigma) with
    21λ1=0\lambda_1 = 0 and λ2=−∞\lambda_2 = -\infty. For every ω\omega its slow space
    22{x∈X:λω(x)≤λ2(ω)}=ker⁡φω\{x \in X : \lambda_\omega(x) \le \lambda_2(\omega)\} = \ker \varphi_\omega
    23belongs to the Grassmannian GX\mathcal{G} X, yet there is no measurable map
    24W:Ω→GXW : \Omega \to \mathcal{G} X with W(ω)W(\omega) equal to this slow space for every ω\omega.
    25So separability of XX alone does not make the slow spaces of the Oseledets decomposition
    26measurable.
    27
    28The mechanism is that of Horan (2020, Remark 4.5.7), who observes that for a family of
    29Perron–Frobenius operators on BVBV at mutual distance at least 25\tfrac25, measurability of ω↦Lω\omega \mapsto \mathcal{L}_\omega
    30 would make arbitrary sets of base points measurable. Lee (2024, Example
    3135) gives a version over a full shift, on ℓ1(N0)\ell^1(\mathbb{N}_0) with φω\varphi_\omega summing from
    32i=1i = 1; that functional vanishes on e0e_0, so here the sum runs over all coordinates.
    33-/
    34
    35namespace Lax606786.SlowSpaceNonmeasurability
    36
    37open MeasureTheory
    38open Lax606786.BanachGrassmannian Lax606786.Cocycles
    39
    40/-- `ℓ¹(ℤ)` with its Borel `σ`-algebra. -/
    41noncomputable instance instMeasurableSpaceL1 : MeasurableSpace (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1) :=
    42 borel _
    43
    44instance instBorelSpaceL1 : BorelSpace (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1) := ⟨rfl⟩
    45
    46/-- The rotation angle `α = √2 mod 1`. -/
    47noncomputable def angle : AddCircle (1 : ℝ) := ((Real.sqrt 2 : ℝ) : AddCircle (1 : ℝ))
    48
    49/-- `s_i(ω) = 1` if the representative of `ω + iα` in `[0, 1)` lies in `[0, 1/2)`, else `-1`. -/
    50noncomputable def sign (ω : AddCircle (1 : ℝ)) (i : ℤ) : ℝ :=
    51 if ((AddCircle.equivIco 1 0 (ω + i • angle) : ℝ)) < 1 / 2 then 1 else -1
    52
    53/-- `ℓ¹(ℤ)` is separable, and the cocycle `𝓛_ω x = (Σᵢ sᵢ(ω) xᵢ) e₀` over the rotation by `α`
    54of the circle with Lebesgue measure is quasicompact; its slow space `{x | λ_ω(x) ≤ λ₂(ω)}` is
    55`ker φ_ω` and lies in `𝒢X` for every `ω`, but no measurable map `Ω → 𝒢X` takes it as value at
    56every `ω`. -/
    57axiom exists_cocycle_slowSpace_not_measurable :
    58 TopologicalSpace.SeparableSpace (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1) ∧
    59 ∃ R : Cocycle (AddCircle (1 : ℝ)) (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1),
    60 R.μ = volume ∧ (∀ ω, R.σ ω = ω + angle) ∧
    61 (∀ ω x, R.L ω x = (∑' i, sign ω i * x i) • lp.single 1 0 (1 : ℝ)) ∧
    62 R.IsQuasicompact ∧
    63 (∀ ω, {x | R.lambdaAt ω x ≤ R.lambda 2 ω} = {x | ∑' i, sign ω i * x i = 0}) ∧
    64 (∀ ω, ∃ W : Grassmannian (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1),
    65 ((W.1 : Submodule ℝ _) : Set _) = {x | R.lambdaAt ω x ≤ R.lambda 2 ω}) ∧
    66 ¬ ∃ W : AddCircle (1 : ℝ) → Grassmannian (lp (fun _ : ℤ => ℝ) 1), Measurable W ∧
    67 ∀ ω, (((W ω).1 : Submodule ℝ _) : Set _) = {x | R.lambdaAt ω x ≤ R.lambda 2 ω}
    68
    69end Lax606786.SlowSpaceNonmeasurability
    70
    Show Proof

    Discussion

    Ask a question or add context. Endorsements and structured flags are kept in the review panel above.

    Loading discussion…